One of the household chores that every family must perform daily or weekly is washing clothes, with the crucial support of detergents. Currently, the most commonly used detergents for laundry are powder detergent and liquid detergent.
The names of these two detergents highlight their differences in form: powder and liquid. Specifically, powder detergent is a fluffy powder, usually white interspersed with tiny blue and red granules, and has a light fragrance. The composition of powder detergent includes chemical compounds such as Alkylbenzene sulfonates.
In contrast to powder detergent, liquid detergent is in the form of a liquid solution. Liquid detergent typically comes in blue, white, or pink colors. Many users note that when pouring liquid detergent, the fragrance is more pronounced and somewhat stronger than that of powder detergent.
Powder detergent and liquid detergent are two popular types of cleaning agents, but which one is better? (Illustrative image).
Between the two types of detergents, many users wonder which is truly better for washing clothes. To provide an answer, industry experts have analyzed various factors and aspects to outline the advantages and disadvantages of each type. This allows users to make an informed decision based on their family’s needs.
1. Stain Removal Ability
The first factor that users care about when choosing between powder detergent and liquid detergent is their stain removal ability. According to Whirlpool, a U.S. corporation with over 100 years of history specializing in providing and advising on household products and appliances, powder detergent contains strong cleaning compounds, which makes it more effective at removing stains compared to liquid detergent. Particularly, it works especially well on stubborn stains like clay or mud.
This is also emphasized by Jennifer Ahoni, North America Communications Director for Fabric Science at Procter & Gamble, in Consumer Reports. However, liquid detergent is recommended for tackling grease-related stains. “Most liquid detergents contain ethoxylate alcohol in their formulation, making them effective at removing grease stains,” noted the website Taste of Home.
For clothes with many stubborn stains, powder detergent will do a better job. (Illustrative image).
However, due to its strong cleaning agents, powder detergent may not protect clothes and fabrics as effectively as liquid detergent. An article on WireCutter from NYTimes states that clothes washed with powder detergent may become scratched and less soft.
2. Convenience
The second factor to consider is convenience. The site Taste of Home rates liquid detergent as having an advantage in this regard, meaning it is more convenient compared to powder detergent. Whether washing by hand or machine, users can easily pour liquid detergent directly onto clothes. Additionally, liquid detergent dissolves easily and does not leave residues like powder detergent.
Liquid detergent is also considered suitable for both hand washing and machine washing. In contrast, powder detergent is primarily recommended for hand washing. During washing cycles, especially in cold water, powder detergent may not fully dissolve, leading to suboptimal cleaning results and potentially damaging the appliance.
Liquid detergent is considered more convenient as it is suitable for both hand washing and machine washing. (Illustrative image).
3. Cost of Use
Surveys show that currently, most liquid detergents are priced higher than powder detergents. Specifically, powder detergent costs about 40,000 VND/kg, while liquid detergent is priced at nearly 60,000 VND/liter.
User habits can also lead to higher costs and waste of detergent when washing clothes. Therefore, users should carefully consider the dosage when using both powder and liquid detergents. Typically, dosage recommendations are indicated on the product packaging. Using too little or too much is not advisable. Using too little will compromise cleaning effectiveness, while using too much may lead to unprocessed detergent or soap residue.
Whether using powder detergent or liquid detergent, users should use the appropriate amount. (Illustrative image).
Conclusion
In conclusion, after analyzing various factors and aspects, experts agree that there is no definitive answer to the question: “Which is better, powder detergent or liquid detergent?” Each type of detergent has its own advantages and disadvantages and is suited to different user needs.
Experts advise that if a family wants to tackle stubborn stains like dirt or prefers hand washing while keeping costs down, powder detergent is a good choice. If a family wants to better protect their clothes, especially for children’s garments, and frequently uses a washing machine, liquid detergent may serve this purpose well.
Currently, in addition to regular powder and liquid detergents, multifunctional laundry pods have emerged in the market. Shaped like small square or rectangular candies, these pods contain both liquid detergent, fabric softener, and fragrance. Users may also consider this option for their laundry process.
In addition to liquid and powder detergents, the newly popular laundry pods are gaining traction. (Illustrative image).
